Payroll Supervisor
All Career • Branson West, Missouri • Full Time
Posted on Tue, Jul 21, 2026
Herschend is the world’s largest family-owned themed attractions company, with 12,000+ passionate hosts collectively entertaining 15 million families each year.
The heart of Herschend’s success has long been the world-renowned hospitality that’s rooted in our DNA. We call it Heartspitality®. It’s a unique culture that blends our ethos of Leading with Love and our purpose of Bringing Families Closer Together by Creating Memories Worth Repeating® to create real impact and joy that spreads through our hosts to our guests and out into our communities.
Herschend’s portfolio of more than two dozen beloved family entertainment brands across North America includes iconic award-winning destinations such as Dollywood® Parks & Resorts, Silver Dollar City® Company, Adventure Aquarium®, Callaway Resort & Gardens®, Kentucky Kingdom Theme & Water Park®, Newport Aquarium®, The Vancouver Aquarium® and Wild Adventures®. In addition to its premier themed attractions, Herschend is proud to steward the World-Famous Harlem Globetrotters® legacy and provide immersive content and experiences through our Herschend Entertainment Studios® and Pink Adventure Tours® brands.
As an equal-opportunity employer, we strive to provide environments where every host, guest, and partner feel welcome, valued, and loved. We firmly believe that words and actions matter, which is why all individuals are to be treated equally and with respect.
The Payroll Supervisor is responsible for leading a team of three in a fast-paced, high-volume environment to complete accurate and timely multi-state payroll and related duties. This position leads by demonstrating our “Leading with Love” culture – leading through humility, empathy and integrity to foster a culture of trust, collaboration, accountability and respect. The Payroll Supervisor will act as back up to the team and the Payroll Manager as needed.
ESSENTIAL DUTIES & RESPONSIBILITIES
Lead the team:
· Lead and support the payroll team in a manner consistent with Herschend’s “Leading with Love” approach.
· Use judgement to escalate processing and/or team issues to manager as necessary.
· Balance customer service to employees and property management with efficiency of operation, providing excellent quality customer service to internal employees as well as outside sources.
· Maintain payroll guidelines and drive standardization and efficiency by establishing, writing and updating desk procedures.
· Responsible for training of new hires within the Payroll team.
· Use independent judgment, logic and analytical skills in problem solving.
· Practice flexible leadership, professional management skills, and consultative and participative decision-making skills.
· Train to serve as backup to the Payroll Manager and coordinators.
Oversee and support timely and accurate payroll processing:
· Ensure timely and accurate completion of all payrolls while ensuring compliance with federal, state and local laws.
· Review and approve payrolls prior to finalization, correcting errors as necessary.
· Work collaboratively to obtain compliance with payroll timelines and procedures.
· Act as a resource to Payroll Coordinators for all payroll related processing issues, including troubleshooting system issues, working with technical support, IT and others as required.
· Maintain complete confidentiality of employee information.
Provide leadership and oversight for all Payroll Tax functions; support internal and external audits:
· Lead quarter end and year end activities, payroll tax oversight and ad hoc projects.
· Perform reconciliations and balancing of payroll liabilities each pay period.
· Lead auditing, balancing and finalization of quarter and year end data and reporting.
· Responsible for working with our third-party payroll tax administrator to submit, track and resolve all tax inquiries.
· Collect data for Workers Compensation audits, 401K audits, etc. and work with internal teams for submission.
Contribute to a culture of Continuous Improvement:
· Evaluate payroll practices critically and continually to identify, and implement, opportunities for increased effectiveness, efficiency, accuracy and compliance with federal, state and local laws.
Other duties may be assigned.
EXPERIENCE & EDUCATION
· BS in Accounting/Finance or related field; or equivalent experience.
· 2 - 3 years' progressive experience in Accounting/Finance field, experience in full-cycle payroll administration preferred.
· Strong leadership skills with demonstrated mindset of continuous improvement, ability to lead others with compassion, flexibility adapting to changes in support of the business and proven record of meeting deadlines.
· Knowledge of payroll processing best practices, payroll tax administration and filing, and other payroll disciplines preferred.
· Multi-state payroll tax experience preferred.
· Experience with UltiPro (UKG) and/or Workday preferred.
SKILLS & QUALIFICATIONS
· Strong communication and interpersonal skills.
· Advanced knowledge of spreadsheet preparation utilizing Microsoft Excel.
· Ability to work effectively with others in a friendly, professional manner.
· Strong attention to detail.
· Self-supervised and disciplined to prioritize and complete work on a timely basis.
· Demonstrated ability to lead with humility, respect and a people-first mindset while fostering a positive and supportive team culture.
· Handle confidential information responsibly.
AuditFriendly salary estimate
The employer did not post a salary for this role. Based on AuditFriendly's salary intelligence model (comparable live postings, role, seniority, and location), we estimate base pay of $94,000–$135,000 per year (median ~$110,000). This is an AuditFriendly estimate, not an employer-provided figure.
More live payroll_manager roles
- Assistant Payroll Manager at Cathay Bank — El Monte, California, United States
- Payroll Manager (12-18 Month Contract) - Newcastle West, Limerick at Sysco — Limerick, Ireland
- Manager, Payroll & Equity Administration at Celldex Therapeutics — Needham, Massachusetts, US
- Payroll Manager at Raymond James — Saint Petersburg, Florida, United States
- Senior Payroll Manager at Sunrise Senior Living Mgmt — McLean, Virginia, United States
- Payroll Manager at Sun Mar Health Care — Garden Grove, California, United States
- Payroll Manager at CPH Management — San Juan, Puerto Rico, United States
- Manager, Payroll at Chewy — Plantation, Florida, United States
- Senior Payroll Manager at FRIDAY & Associates — San Jose, California, United States
- Payroll Manager, Centralized Operations at Go Auto — Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
- Payroll Manager, Centralized Operations (Go Auto Corporate) at Go Auto — Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
- Payroll Manager at Opendoor — Toronto, Canada
- Senior Manager, Payroll at UT Health San Antonio — San Antonio, Texas, United States
- Senior Manager, Global Payroll at Wal-Mart Associates — Bentonville, Arkansas, United States
- Client Payroll Team Lead at IRIS (Remote)
- Payroll Manager at Xaira Therapeutics — South San Francisco, California, United States
- Payroll Manager at Alliance HCM — Spring, TX, United States
- Payroll Manager at Current — Tampa, Florida, United States
- Payroll Manager at OOS Management — Brooklyn, New York, United States
- Office and Payroll Manager at Tarkett — West Linn, Oregon, United States
- Payroll Manager at Valeris — Morrisville, North Carolina, United States
- Payroll Manager at East Boston Neighborhood Health Center Corporation — Revere, Massachusetts, US
- Payroll Manager at American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida (Remote)
- Senior Manager, Global Payroll & HR Shared Services at Integra LifeSciences — Princeton, New Jersey, United States
- Payroll Manager at University HealthCare Alliance — Newark, New Jersey, United States
- Senior Corporate Payroll Manager at McKesson — Irving, Texas, United States
- Payroll Manager at Amentum — Las Vegas, Nevada, United States
- Senior Manager, Payroll at MTM (Remote)
- Payroll Manager — Syracuse, NY, US
- Payroll Manager at Solargaines — Cockeysville, Maryland, US
- Payroll Centre Team Lead, HR Operations at OECD — Paris, France
- Manager, Payroll at Los Angeles County Museum Of Natural History Foundation — Los Angeles, California, United States
- Global Payroll Manager at Turn2Partners — New York, New York, United States
- Deputy Payroll Manager - NA at Computershare — Louisville, Kentucky, United States
- Payroll Supervisor at Hamilton Southeastern Schools — Fishers, IN, US
- Payroll Manager at State of Illinois — Springfield, Illinois, United States
- Office and Payroll Manager at Tarkett Sports — West Linn, Oregon, United States
- Manager, Payroll at Current External — Toronto, Ontario, Canada
- Payroll Manager at University of Denver — Denver, Colorado, United States
- Payroll Manager at Ignite Human Capital — Poway, California, United States
- Payroll Manager at Self-Help — Durham, North Carolina, United States