Payroll Supervisor
Life Unlimited • Kansas City, Missouri • Full Time
Posted on Fri, Sep 25, 2026
Job Description
Job Title: Payroll Supervisor
Department: Finance
Reports To: Chief Accounting Officer
FLSA: Exempt
Salary Range starting at 60K DOE
SUMMARY
The Payroll Supervisor is responsible for the day-to-day supervision and administration of Life Unlimited�s payroll function, ensuring employees are paid accurately, timely, and in compliance with all applicable federal and state laws, organizational policies, and other oversight requirements. This position serves as the organization�s payroll subject matter expert and provides direct oversight of payroll operations, including weekly payroll processing, payroll compliance, timekeeping administration, payroll reporting, tax compliance, garnishments, leave administration, and employee payroll support. The Payroll Supervisor supervises the payroll team and collaborates closely with Human Resources, Finance, and operational leadership to ensure payroll processes support organizational objectives while maintaining strong internal controls.
BASIC FUNCTIONS AND GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES:
� Supervise weekly payroll processing for all employees, ensuring accurate and timely payment of wages.
� Direct and support Payroll staff by providing leadership, coaching, training, performance management, and workload prioritization.
� Review payroll for accuracy, including overtime, shift differentials, holiday pay, incentive compensation, retroactive adjustments, leave balances, and other earnings and deductions.
� Ensure compliance with the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), IRS regulations, wage and hour laws, and all other applicable federal and state payroll requirements.
� Administer payroll tax reporting, garnishments, benefit deductions, 401k retirement contributions, and other required withholdings.
� Reconcile payroll registers, payroll liability accounts, benefit deductions, and payroll-related general ledger accounts in collaboration with Finance.
� Coordinate payroll activities related to new hires, promotions, transfers, compensation changes, incentive programs, and employee separations.
� Provide training and ongoing education to managers and employees regarding payroll policies, timekeeping procedures, leave administration, and payroll best practices.
� Monitor and maintain the organization's timekeeping system, identifying discrepancies and working collaboratively with department managers to resolve exceptions.
� Prepare payroll reports, labor analyses, and supporting documentation for leadership, audits, and regulatory agencies.
� Maintain payroll records and documentation in accordance with organizational policies and applicable record retention requirements.
� Assist with annual payroll activities including W-2 preparation, year-end reconciliation, payroll tax reporting, and external audits.
� Identify opportunities to improve payroll processes, strengthen internal controls, and increase operational efficiency through automation and standardization.
� Serve as the primary payroll resource for employees, managers, Human Resources, Finance, and external agencies regarding payroll-related questions and issues.
� Participate in payroll system upgrades, testing, implementations, and process improvement initiatives.
� Perform other duties as assigned.
Physical Expectations
This position requires extended periods of sitting with some periods of walking and standing. It may also require bending, kneeling, and/or stooping and climbing stairs. An individual in this
position may need to drive a vehicle to resources in the community. There may be extended periods of using a computer and/or calculator.
Working Conditions
This position operates in an office setting. This role routinely uses standard office equipment such as computers, phones, photocopies, filing cabinets and fax machines.
QUALIFICATIONS
Minimum of five (5) years of progressively responsible payroll experience, including processing high-volume payroll.
Experience processing payroll for a complex hourly workforce.
Strong knowledge of payroll administration, wage and hour laws, payroll taxes, garnishments, benefit deductions, and leave administration.
Experience administering payroll for employees with overtime, shift differentials, holiday pay, incentive compensation, and other variable pay components.
Strong analytical, organizational, problem-solving, and customer service skills.
High degree of accuracy, confidentiality, and attention to detail.
Proficiency with Microsoft Excel and payroll/timekeeping/HRIS software.
Excellent verbal and written communication skills.
High School Diploma or Equivalent
Valid driver's license and reliable transportation.
Must receive seasonal flu vaccination.
PREFERRED QUALIFICATIONS
Bachelor's degree in Accounting, Business Administration, Human Resources, Finance, or a related field.
Supervisory or team leadership experience or demonstrated leadership responsibilities in payroll operations.
Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) designation.
Experience with Workforce, Proliant, UKG, ADP, Workday, Dayforce, Paycom, or similar Human Capital Management systems.
Experience with Sage Intacct or integrated payroll accounting systems.
Experience supporting payroll and 401k audits and financial reconciliations.
Experience within healthcare, behavioral health, human services, or other 24/7 operational environments.
Equal Opportunity Employer
AuditFriendly salary estimate
The employer did not post a salary for this role. Based on AuditFriendly's salary intelligence model (comparable live postings, role, seniority, and location), we estimate base pay of $93,000–$135,000 per year (median ~$112,000). This is an AuditFriendly estimate, not an employer-provided figure.
More live payroll_manager roles
- Payroll Manager at Apply for the Payroll Manager job — Lakeland, Florida, United States
- Payroll Manager at Bitdeer Technologies Group — Austin, TX, United States
- Payroll Supervisor at State of Montana — Helena, Montana, United States
- Field Payroll Supervisor, union experience at Rosendin — Sterling, Virginia, US
- Field Payroll Supervisor at Rosendin — Sterling, VA, US
- Field Payroll Supervisor - union experience at Rosendin — Sterling, VA, United States
- Payroll Manager at GSFoods — Ontario, CA, US
- Payroll Manager at Atlantic Projects Company Limited — Limerick, Ireland
- Assistant Payroll Manager at Another Source — Claremont, California, United States
- Sr. Administrative & Payroll Manager at Riley Power Group — Rock Hill, SC, United States
- Workday Payroll Lead at The Squires Group (Remote)
- HR & Payroll Manager at TEEG — North Grosvenordale, Connecticut, United States
- Payroll Supervisor at System High Corporation — Chantilly, Virginia, United States
- Senior Business Systems Lead, Payroll & Time (Dayforce) at Lyft — Toronto, Canada
- Automotive Payroll Supervisor at Sheehy Honda — Alexandria, Virginia, US
- Payroll Manager (Contractor) at National University (Remote)
- Senior Manager, Payroll and People Operations at Versaterm — Mesa, Arizona, United States
- Manager Payroll at Sotera Health — Broadview Heights, Ohio, United States
- Payroll Supervisor at Esri — Redlands, California, United States
- Senior Manager - HRIS & Payroll at KDC One — Longueuil, Quebec, Canada
- Payroll Manager, US at American Tower — Boston, Massachusetts, United States
- International Payroll Manager at Broadridge — 2 Locations
- Senior Payroll Manager at OSI Careers — Warrenville, Illinois, United States
- Sr. Payroll Manager at OSI Careers — Warrenville, IL, US
- Senior Payroll Manager at C.A.C. INDUSTRIES, INC. — Long Island City, New York, United States
- SAP HCM Payroll & Success Factors Lead Consultant at Business Needs — Omaha, NE, US
- Payroll Manager at IFAC — Kilkenny, Ireland
- Payroll Manager at Wings Credit Union — Colorado Springs, Colorado, United States
- Senior Payroll Manager at CBRE Government & Defense Services — United States
- Benefits and Payroll Manager at Nutramax Laboratories — Lancaster, South Carolina, US
- Payroll Manager at Summit Health CityMD — Rocky Hill, Connecticut, United States
- Payroll Manager - Connecticut at Summit Health CityMD — Rocky Hill, CT, United States
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Payroll Manager: a median of $104,500 across 813 priced postings. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure