Finance Manager

First Baptist Church South Hill • Chesapeake, VA • Full Time • $75,000–$85,000 / year

Posted on Mon, Oct 5, 2026

First Baptist Church South Hill
Chesapeake, VA | Hybrid
Full-Time | $75,000–$85,000 annually
About the Opportunity:First Baptist Church South Hill is seeking an experienced, detail-oriented Finance Manager to oversee the church's day-to-day accounting and financial operations.
This position is ideal for an accounting or finance professional who combines strong technical skills with integrity, sound judgment, and a heart for serving in a ministry environment. The Finance Manager will work closely with the Business Administrator to maintain accurate financial records, administer payroll, prepare financial reports, support budgeting and audits, strengthen internal controls, and help ensure responsible stewardship of church resources.
What You'll DoAs Finance Manager, you will:

Maintain the general ledger, chart of accounts, and supporting accounting records.
Record financial transactions and prepare general and adjusting journal entries.
Manage monthly and year-end closing activities.
Reconcile bank accounts, credit card statements, contributions, deposits, and other balance-sheet accounts.
Track and report restricted and designated funds accurately.
Manage accounts payable, vendor payments, employee reimbursements, W-9s, and related vendor records.
Ensure contributions/donations and other revenues are accurately posted and reconciled with bank deposits, membership contribution system and accounting records.
Process or coordinate semi-monthly payroll for salaried and hourly employees.
Review payroll deductions, taxes, benefits, and authorized changes for accuracy.
Complete payroll tax filings and reconciliations, including Forms 941, W-2, and W-3.
Process retirement contributions and support workers' compensation and other payroll-related reporting.
Prepare monthly financial statements, cash-flow reports, budget-to-actual reports, and ministry/department financial reports.
Identify financial variances, unusual transactions, trends, and discrepancies requiring attention.
Assist with preparation and administration of the church's annual operating budget.
Prepare financial records, schedules, and supporting documentation for audits and financial reviews.
Maintain accurate, organized, confidential, and audit-ready financial records.
Establish and follow financial policies and internal control procedures.
Recommend improvements to accounting procedures, workflows, documentation, and financial systems.
Provide financial guidance and support to church staff, ministry leaders, volunteers, auditors, and leadership as appropriate.

What We're Looking For:Required Qualifications:

Bachelor's degree in Accounting, Finance, Business, or a related field.
At least 3 years of progressively responsible accounting, bookkeeping, finance, or related financial experience.
At least 2 years of hands-on payroll processing experience, including payroll taxes, deductions, reconciliations, and reporting.
Experience with general ledger accounting, accounts payable, account reconciliations, financial reporting, and month-end/year-end closing.
Experience supporting budgets, audits, financial controls, or fund accounting.
Working knowledge of federal and state payroll tax requirements.
Strong Microsoft Excel skills and proficiency with Microsoft Word, Outlook, and PowerPoint.
Experience using computerized accounting and payroll systems.
Strong analytical, reconciliation, research, and problem-solving skills.
Excellent attention to detail, organization, and ability to manage recurring deadlines.
Strong written and verbal communication skills.
Ability to maintain strict confidentiality involving employee, donor, payroll, financial, and church information.

Preferred Qualifications:

3–5 years of accounting or financial management experience.
Experience with Paycor, PayDay, or comparable payroll systems.
Experience processing payroll for both salaried and hourly employees.
Experience with nonprofit, church, or other mission-driven fund accounting.
Experience with accounting and church-management software.
Additional accounting, payroll, nonprofit finance, or financial-management training or certification.
CPA certification is beneficial but not required.

Ministry & Culture Fit:Because this role serves within a church ministry, the successful candidate should demonstrate:

Personal integrity, reliability, professionalism, and sound judgment.
A servant-minded and collaborative approach.
Flexibility and a commitment to the mission and vision of First Baptist Church South Hill.
A meaningful and growing personal relationship with Jesus Christ.

Work Environment:This is a full-time, hybrid position based at First Baptist Church South Hill in Chesapeake, Virginia.The role involves regular use of computers, spreadsheets, payroll systems, and financial software. Some periods may require additional flexibility due to payroll processing, month-end and year-end closing, budgeting, audits, and tax-reporting deadlines. Attendance at selected staff meetings, leadership meetings, or church conferences may also be required.
Compensation:$75,000–$85,000 annually, based on qualifications and experience.
Join Our Team:If you are an experienced finance professional who values accuracy, accountability, confidentiality, and responsible stewardship—and you would welcome the opportunity to use your professional expertise in support of a church ministry—we invite you to apply for the Finance Manager position with First Baptist Church South Hill.Thank you for your interest in serving with First Baptist Church South Hill. We appreciate every application received. Due to the anticipated volume of applications, we will contact only those candidates selected to move forward in the interview process.

More live finance_manager roles

Browse all live jobs · Accounting & finance salary data

What the data says about this job

Advertised pay for Finance Manager: a median of $129,015 across 3,331 priced postings. This posting advertises $75,000 to $85,000, 38% below that median. Explore the market

Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure

View the interactive listing →