Controller
New Hope of Indiana • Indianapolis, Indiana • Full Time
Posted on Sat, Nov 14, 2026
WHO WE ARE
At New Hope of Indiana, we are not just an organization; we are a community dedicated to empowering individuals with disabilities to live their most fulfilling lives. Established as the largest not-for-profit provider of residential services in Marion County, we pioneer transformative initiatives that foster inclusivity, independence, and a culture of compassion.
Our mission is clear: to actively support individuals with disabilities through comprehensive services and unwavering advocacy for human dignity. We envision a world where everyone belongs, and our community embraces and welcomes individuals with disabilities, making inclusion the norm.
WHAT WE ARE LOOKING FOR –
The Controller oversees operational processes within the accounting department, ensuring accuracy, integrity, and regulatory compliance for all accounting activities. Reporting directly to the CFO, this role translates daily operational transactions into decision-ready financial intelligence. The Controller directly manages day-to-day accounting, fund accounting, grant administration, internal controls, and audit readiness.
WHAT YOUR DAY TO DAY LOOKS LIKE
You will utilize your skills and expertise in three (3) functional areas:
Financial Management & Reporting
- Oversee day-to-day financial operations, including general ledger, accounts payable, accounts receivable, payroll, and month-end/year-end close.
- Prepare and analyze timely, accurate monthly, quarterly, and annual financial statements in accordance with GAAP.
- Review organizational cash flow forecasting.
- Provide detailed financial reports and budget variance analyses for executive leadership and the Board’s audit/finance committees.
Grant & Fund Accounting
- Assist with grant administration to ensure expenditures consistently align with grant, corporate, and foundation donor restrictions.
- Coordinate with program managers to provide budget-to-actual visibility and ensure proper revenue recognition for restricted gifts.
Compliance, Internal Controls & Audits
- Maintain and fortify internal accounting controls to protect assets and ensure programmatic integrity.
- Assist with several annual external audits, including preparing schedules and providing documentation to auditors.
- Assist with the preparation and filing of IRS Form 990 and all other Medicaid filings.
- Other duties as assigned.
WHAT YOU BRING TO THE TABLE
Required:
- A bachelor’s degree in accounting, finance, or business administration
- Five (5) years of experience in accounting.
- Strong knowledge of nonprofit GAAP, including net asset classifications and grant accounting.
- Ability to analyze financial data and prepare financial reports, statements, and projections.
- Proficient with core financial & HRIS programs, e.g. – Microsoft Dynamics GP, Sage, Oracle NetSuite, UKG, PeopleSoft, ADP
- Advanced proficiency in Microsoft Excel.
- This role requires professional written and verbal communication as well as interpersonal skills.
- Ability to work with tight timeframes and simultaneously manage several projects.
- Ability to participate in and facilitate group meetings.
Preferred:
- One (1) year of experience in a nonprofit accounting or assistant controller role.
- CPA (Certified Public Accountant) or MBA.
BENEFITS THAT WE OFFER
New Hope recognizes the importance of a work environment that fosters respect, dignity, diversity, teamwork, personal growth, training, and development. We maintain a compassionate culture that supports work/life balance and we believe in the power of our associates. Each associate enjoys benefits including:
- 403(b) Retirement Plan with Employer Match
- Attractive Medical/Dental/Vision plans
- 100% employer paid short-term/long-term disability
- 100% employer paid basic life and AD&D insurance
- Generous Paid Time Off accrual
- Tuition Reimbursement
- Employee Assistance Program
- Employee Referral Bonus
New Hope of Indiana is committed to supporting inclusion, belonging and accessibility in all areas of our work. As an Equal Opportunity Employer, New Hope of Indiana champions a workplace where every individual is respected, valued, and empowered to succeed.
More live controller roles
- Corporate Controller / Finance Manager at SBT Global — Cerritos, CA, US
- Financial and Business Controller at Sterk in Matches — Sliedrecht, Zuid-Holland, Netherlands
- Controller at Best Choice Products — Newport Beach, California, United States
- Finance Controller at Green Lake Conference Center — Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
- Valuations Controller VP Director at Mizuho — New York, New York, United States
- Controller at 512Financial — Dallas, TX, United States
- Controller at MarSell Wellness Center — Ontario, California, United States
- Controller at Seneca Holdings — Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States
- Manager, Financial Controller at LA28 — Los Angeles, California, United States
- Administrative Manager Controller at Saige Partners — Terrebonne, Canada
- Controller at Recovery Monitoring Solutions — Dallas, TX, USA
- Senior Business Controller at WSP Nederland — Nieuwegein, Netherlands
- Controller at Silver Oak Cellars — Healdsburg, CA, United States
- Site Controller at Cleveland-Cliffs Steel — New Carlisle, Indiana, United States
- Controller at RealManage — Pembroke Pines, Florida, United States
- Financial Controller at Edison Properties — Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
- Controller at Peak Utility Services Group — Fort Worth, Texas, United States
- Plant Controller at Johnson Controls — Gilbert, Arizona, United States
- Interim Business Controller at Berenschot Groep — Amsterdam, NH, Netherlands
- Controller at Preferred CFO — United States
- Assistant Plant Controller at Jbs Usa — Perry, IA, United States
- Controller at SunSteel — Vancouver, WA, USA
- Controller at CI Azumano — Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States
- Vice President, Controller at Power Factors — Brossard, QC, Canada
- Business Controller at True Hire — Overijssel, Netherlands
- Controller at OSC — Sioux Falls, South Dakota, United States
- Housing Controller at Catholic Charities Serving Central Washington — Yakima, Washington, United States
- Site Controller at Compass Minerals Careers — Ogden, Utah, United States
- Controller at Horizon Chemical — Arden Hills, Minnesota, United States
- Business Controller at Richemont — Amsterdam, North Holland, Netherlands
- Controller at Lalor Dental — Johnson City, New York, United States
- Financial Controller at BellAir — Raleigh, North Carolina, United States
- Transformational Controller at Acclarity (Remote)
- Controller at White Ash Group — Lower Sackville, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Market Controller at SPCP/Southeast Medical Group — Warner Robins, Georgia, United States
- Controller at Rochester Hearing & Speech Center — Rochester, New York, United States
- Associate Vice President, Controller at Delta Dental of New Jersey — New Jersey, United States
- Vice President, Corporate Controller at Propio — Overland Park, Kansas, United States
- Corporate Controller at Horsburgh & Scott Company — Cleveland, OH, United States
- Portfolio Controller at Pro Btp — Paris, France, France
- Portfolio Controller F/H at Pro Btp — Paris, France, France
- Controller at International House Hotel — New Orleans, LA, United States
- Controller at ACGME — Chicago, IL, United States
- Controller at Boys & Girls Club Fox Valley — Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
- Business Controller at Bright Professionals — Amsterdam, North Holland, Netherlands
- Controller at Solutions 2 GO — Brampton, Ontario, Canada
- Controller at Leo Berwick — Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
- Accounting Controller at Mountain Lake Corp — Lake Wales, FL, USA
- Controller, Operations at Compass Group — Moscow, ID, United States
- Controller at Paradromics — Austin, TX, United States
- Divisional Controller at Ecl — Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada
- Controller/Senior Accountant at A Quality Facility Services — Canton, OH, USA
- Controller at American Iron and Metal — Mirabel, QC, CA
- Controller at Epiq Design Solutions — Rolling Meadows, Illinois, United States
- Controller at St. Mark’s Episcopal School — Houston, Texas, United States
- Associate Controller at College of Western Idaho — Nampa, ID, USA
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Controller: a median of $130,000 across 6,094 priced postings. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure