Payroll and Benefits Administrator
HR One • Syracuse, New York • Full Time • $30–$40 / hour
Posted on Fri, Sep 25, 2026
Sutton Real Estate is seeking a Payroll/Benefits Administrator to be responsible for the accurate and timely administration of weekly payroll, employee benefits, and related financial and administrative processes for multiple properties managed by Sutton Real Estate.
This position requires a high level of accuracy, confidentiality, organization, and attention to detail, as well as the ability to effectively communicate with employees, Property Managers, and internal departments.
The Payroll/Benefits Administrator will serve as a resource for employees and management regarding payroll, benefits, and related questions while ensuring compliance with applicable laws, regulations, and company policies.
Requirements
Essential Duties & Responsibilities
Payroll Administration
· Process weekly payroll for multiple properties using Payentry payroll software.
· Review and verify employee timecards to ensure hours worked, overtime, PTO, and other payroll-related information are accurate and complete.
· Communicate with Property Managers regarding timecard approvals, discrepancies, and required corrections.
· Review payroll data for accuracy prior to processing and ensure employees are paid accurately and on time.
· Prepare payroll-related journal entries and enter transactions into the accounting system.
· Maintain accurate and confidential payroll records and documentation.
· Research, investigate, and resolve payroll discrepancies and employee inquiries in a timely and professional manner.
· Process wage garnishments, tax levies, and other court-ordered deductions in accordance with applicable requirements.
· Ensure payroll practices comply with applicable federal, state, and local wage and hour requirements, as well as company policies and procedures.
· Identify payroll errors and make appropriate corrections while maintaining accurate documentation.
· Provide timely and accurate responses to employee questions regarding payroll, deductions, tax forms, and other payroll-related matters.
· Maintain confidentiality of employee compensation, personal information, and other sensitive payroll data.
Benefits Administration
· Administer Sutton's employee benefit programs, including:
o Medical Insurance
o Dental Insurance
o Life Insurance
o 401(k)
o SIMPLE IRA
o Paid Time Off (PTO)
o Sick Time
o Paid Family Leave
· Process employee benefit enrollments, changes, qualifying life events, and terminations accurately and within established deadlines.
· Coordinate and administer the annual open enrollment process, including employee communications and required documentation.
· Respond to employee questions regarding benefit eligibility, enrollment, coverage, and deductions.
· Maintain accurate and confidential benefits records and documentation.
· Coordinate with insurance carriers, benefit providers, and internal personnel to resolve enrollment, billing, and coverage issues.
· Process and coordinate Workers' Compensation and Disability claims and maintain appropriate documentation.
· Ensure benefits administration practices are consistent with company policies and applicable requirements.
Accounts Payable Check Processing
· Print and process accounts payable checks for all properties managed by Sutton.
· Ensure checks are processed accurately and in accordance with established accounting procedures and schedules.
· Maintain appropriate records and documentation related to check processing.
· Coordinate with internal personnel as necessary to resolve discrepancies or processing issues.
Required Skills & Qualifications
· Previous experience in payroll administration, benefits administration, accounting, or a related field.
· Working knowledge of payroll processing and payroll software; experience with Payentry is preferred.
· Basic understanding of accounting principles and journal entries.
· Proficiency with Microsoft Excel and the ability to work with spreadsheets and numerical data.
· Strong attention to detail and commitment to accuracy.
· Strong organizational and time-management skills with the ability to meet recurring payroll and benefits deadlines.
· Ability to identify, research, and resolve discrepancies and errors.
· Ability to handle confidential employee and financial information with discretion and professionalism.
· Strong written and verbal communication skills.
· Ability to provide accurate, timely, and professional responses to employee and management inquiries.
· Familiarity with federal and state payroll forms, including W-4 and W-9 forms, and an understanding of how applicable elections affect payroll processing.
· Ability to work independently while also collaborating effectively with Property Managers, employees, accounting personnel, benefit providers, and other internal stakeholders.
Benefits
Pay Rate Range: $30.00 - $40.00 Depending on Experience
Schedule: 5 Days a Week / 35 Hours Per Week
We are an Equal Opportunity Employer and do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, national origin, age, disability, genetic information, marital status, familial status, military or veteran status, domestic violence victim status, or any other characteristic protected by applicable federal, state, or local laws.
We are committed to providing a workplace free from discrimination and harassment, and we encourage applications from individuals of all backgrounds.
More live payroll_specialist roles
- Payroll Analyst at City of New York — New York City, NY, US
- Payroll Specialist II at City of Des Moines Washington — Des Moines, Washington, United States
- Payroll Specialist - Finance & Risk Management at Pima County — Tucson, Arizona, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Pima County — Tucson, Arizona, US
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Heinens — Warrensville Heights, OH, US
- Payroll Clerk - Nevada at High Light Electric — Las Vegas, Nevada, United States
- Human Resources - Payroll Specialist (Part-Time) at D'Youville University — Buffalo, New York, United States
- International Payroll Analyst at Reddit (Remote)
- Senior Payroll Analyst at KenCrest — Blue Bell, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Aditi Consulting — Plano, Texas, United States
- Payroll Specialist at The Lawrence Paper Company — Lawrence, KS, United States
- Senior Payroll Specialist (Contract) at Trans Mountain — Calgary, Alberta, Canada
- Payroll Specialist at Nicholas Pension Consultants — Folsom, California, United States
- Payroll and Benefits Specialist at ExtendMyTeam — Miami, FL, US
- Senior Payroll Analyst at TEAM Industrial Services — Vlissingen, Netherlands
- Senior Payroll Analyst at National Grid — Syracuse, New York, United States
- Payroll Associate at Stitch Fix (Remote)
- Payroll Clerk at The Salvation Army — Cincinnati, Ohio, US
- Senior Payroll & Benefits Administrator at YipitData (Remote)
- Payroll Specialist- Temporary at StackAdapt — Canada
- Payroll Specialist at Flexcar — Boston, Massachusetts, United States
- Senior Payroll Accountant at Korn Ferry — Los Angeles, California, United States
- Payroll Specialist at System High Corporation — Chantilly, Virginia, United States
- Senior Payroll Accountant at Southland Industries — Garden Grove, CA, US
- Bookkeeping/Payroll Assistant at MS Rio Grande / DBA Mambo Seafood — McAllen, Texas, US
- Payroll Assistant/Timekeeper at City of New York — New York City, NY, United States
- Accounts Payable/Payroll Specialist at 3dB Labs — West Chester, Ohio, United States
- Payroll Accountant at Hoxton Circle — Santa Clara, California, US
- Payroll Specialist at DLL Group — Burlington, Ontario, Canada
- Payroll Specialist II at Asure Software — Nashville, TN, United States
- Payroll Clerk at The MasTec Companies — Miami, Florida, United States
- Payroll Specialist at General Shale — Augusta, Georgia, United States
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Payroll Specialist: a median of $62,711 across 3,319 priced postings. This posting advertises $62,400 to $83,200, 16% above that median. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure