Payroll Administrator
Medical Mutual • Cleveland, Ohio • Full Time
Posted on Fri, Oct 2, 2026
Medical Mutual employees must submit their applications through MySource.
Note: This is a hybrid position located in Brooklyn, OH, with a three-day per week onsite requirement. Candidates must be located in the Cleveland/Brooklyn area.
Founded in 1934, Medical Mutual is the oldest and one of the largest health insurance companies based in Ohio. We provide peace of mind to more than 1.2 million members through our high-quality health, life, disability, dental, vision and indemnity plans. We offer fully insured and self-funded group coverage, including stop loss, as well as Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and individual plans.
Job Summary:
Process payroll related transaction for employees. Compiles, prepares, and maintains payroll reports. Reconciles and analyzes payroll accounts.
Responsibilities:
- Trains, audits, resolves and reconciles transactions and issues with UKG and payroll self-service. Processes and audits benefit and HR transactions.
- Processes, audits and reconciles employee/employer HSA transactions. Funds and uploads contributions to the bank. Resolves issues between HR benefits and the bank.
- Reviews and Interprets court documents. Processes, audits and reconciles wage attachment transactions. Acts as a liaison between the courts, attorneys, agencies and employees to resolve issues.
- Interprets 401(k) rules for employees. Processes, audits and reconciles 401k transactions. Collects data for external agencies, and acts as a liaison between agency and employees.
- Processes, audits and reconciles flexible spending account transactions. Creates and disseminates reports for HR Benefits.
- Trains and educates Managers/employees on expense policies and procedures for Concur. Reviews, audits and processes employee expense reports. Collects data for internal and external auditors.
- Supports and acts as backup for the Sr. Payroll Administrator and Manager.
- Performs departmental administrative responsibilities. Distributes non-negotiables and interoffice mail.
- Completes employer verifications. Responds to employee inquiries regarding payroll
- Performs other duties as assigned. 5%
Qualifications:
Education and Experience:
- Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration or related field preferred. Will consider collective experience, training, and education in lieu of degree.
- 1 year of payroll experience required; 2 years of payroll experience preferred.
Technical Skills and Knowledge:
- Basic accounting and bookkeeping.
- Intermediate Microsoft Office skills.
- Knowledge of corporate expense reimbursement policies.
- Knowledge of 401k rules and limits.
- Knowledge of Flexible Spending Account eligibility requirements and limits.
Medical Mutual is looking to grow our team! We truly value and respect the talents and abilities of all of our employees. That's why we offer an exceptional package that includes:
A Great Place to Work:
- We will provide the equipment you need for this role, including a laptop, monitors, keyboard, mouse and headset.
- Employees have access to on-site fitness centers at many locations, or a gym membership reimbursement when there is no Medical Mutual facility available. Enjoy the use of weights, cardio machines, locker rooms, classes and more.
- On-site cafeteria, serving hot breakfast and lunch, at the Brooklyn, OH headquarters.
- Discounts at many places in and around town, just for being a Medical Mutual team member.
- The opportunity to earn cash rewards for shopping with our customers.
- Business casual attire, including jeans.
Excellent Benefits and Compensation:
- Employee bonus program.
- 401(k) with company match up to 4% and an additional company contribution.
- Health Savings Account with a company matching contribution.
- Excellent medical, dental, vision, life and disability insurance — insurance is what we do best, and we make affordable coverage for our team a priority.
- Access to an Employee Assistance Program, which includes professional counseling, personal and professional coaching, self-help resources and assistance with work/life benefits.
- Company holidays and up to 16 PTO days during the first year of employment with options to carry over unused PTO time.
- After 120 days of service, parental leave for eligible employees who become parents through maternity, paternity or adoption.
An Investment in You:
- Career development programs and classes.
- Mentoring and coaching to help you advance in your career.
- Tuition reimbursement up to $5,250 per year, the IRS maximum.
- Diverse, inclusive and welcoming culture with Business Resource Groups.
About Medical Mutual:
Medical Mutual’s status as a mutual company means we are owned by our policyholders, not stockholders, so we don’t answer to Wall Street analysts or pay dividends to investors. Instead, we focus on developing products and services that allow us to better serve our customers and the communities around us.
There’s a good chance you already know many of our Medical Mutual customers. As the official insurer of everything you love, we are trusted by businesses and nonprofit organizations throughout Ohio to provide high-quality health, life, disability, dental, vision and indemnity plans. We offer fully insured and self-funded group coverage, including stop loss, as well as Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement and individual plans. Our plans provide peace of mind to more than 1.2 million Ohioans.
We’re not just one of the largest health insurance companies based in Ohio, we’re also the longest running. Founded in 1934, we’re proud of our rich history with the communities where we live and work.
We maintain a drug-free workplace and perform pre-employment substance abuse and nicotine testing.
AuditFriendly salary estimate
The employer did not post a salary for this role. Based on AuditFriendly's salary intelligence model (comparable live postings, role, seniority, and location), we estimate base pay of $58,000–$79,000 per year (median ~$69,000). This is an AuditFriendly estimate, not an employer-provided figure.
More live payroll_administrator roles
- Payroll Administrator at PCC Talent Acquisition Portal — Bellevue, Washington, US
- Senior Payroll Administrator at FIREFIGHTERS FIRST FEDERAL CREDIT UNION — US
- Project Accounting and Payroll Administrator at Goins Sweitzer Engineers and Consultants (Remote)
- Payroll Administrator at American Mathematical Society — Providence, Rhode Island, US
- Payroll Administrator at The Salvation Army — Alexandria, Virginia, United States
- Payroll Administrator at Cherry Bekaert — Dulles, Virginia, United States
- Payroll Administrator at Tucson Electric Power — Tucson, Arizona, United States
- Payroll Administrator I, II, or Senior at Tucson Electric Power — Tucson, Arizona, United States
- Payroll Administrator - TEMPORARY - Board Office at Delta — Delta, British Columbia, Canada
- Payroll Administrator, Senior Associate at Ledcor — Vancouver, Canada
- Payroll Administrator-Multi-Client Payroll Specialist (Maternity leave c at POWERGROUP Resources — Hamilton, Canada
- Senior Payroll Administrator at The Vanguard Group — Dublin, Ireland
- Payroll Administrator, Senior Associate at The Vanguard Group — Dublin, Ireland
- Payroll Administrator at PTW Energy Services — Calgary, AB, Canada
- Senior Payroll Administrator at Michels Corporation — Nisku, Alberta, Canada
- Payroll Administrator at Fast Enterprises — Centennial, Colorado, United States
- Part-time Payroll Administrator at EMCOR Group — Oshkosh, Wisconsin, United States
- Principal Payroll Administrator at Lutech Resources — Batam, Kepulauan Riau, Indonesia
- Payroll Administrator at Ledcor — Vancouver, BC
- Payroll Administrator (Temp) at Unknown — Emeryville, California, United States
- Payroll Administrator at Not Specified — Emeryville, California, United States
- Payroll Administrator (Temp) — Emeryville, CA, US
- Payroll Administrator (Temp) at Not Specified — Emeryville, CA, US
- Payroll Administrator at Avoca — Kilmacanoge, County Wicklow, Ireland
- Payroll Administrator at Crescent — West Chester, Pennsylvania, United States
- Senior Payroll Administrator - Michels Canada at Michels Corporation — Nisku, Alberta
- Senior Payroll Administrator at Murphy — Ireland
- Payroll Administrator at Colonial Wholesale Beverage — Dartmouth, Massachusetts, United States
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Payroll Administrator: a median of $61,360 across 633 priced postings. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure