Senior Payroll Specialist
American Auto Auction Group • Carmel, Indiana • Full Time • $68,000–$72,000 / year
Posted on Wed, Nov 18, 2026
Job Title: Senior Payroll Specialist
Location: Carmel, IN (100% On-Site)
Job Type: Full-Time
Why Join America's Auto Auction as a Senior Payroll Specialist?
At America’s Auto Auction, we move fast, take pride in our work, and create an environment where you can stretch your skills and make a real impact. Headquartered in Carmel, IN, we are a leading wholesale vehicle remarketing company with a growing network of auction locations nationwide. If you are a payroll pro who loves solving complex problems and supporting hard-working teams, we want to meet you.
This is a 100% onsite position based at our corporate office in Carmel, Indiana. Remote and hybrid work arrangements are not available for this role.
Rewards for Senior Payroll Specialist
- $68,000.00 - $72,000.00, commensurate with experience
- Comprehensive benefits package including medical, dental, vision, and more
- Matching 401(k)
- Generous paid time off
- Monday - Friday work schedule (early off on Fridays)
- Leading & fast growing international auction company
What You’ll Do as a Senior Payroll Specialist
- Run Multi-State Payroll: Process accurate, on-time bi-weekly payroll for a large workforce across dozens of U.S. auction locations.
- Handle the Complex Stuff: Manage off-cycle checks, retro pay, bonuses, garnishments, tax levies, and child support orders with precision.
- Own System Data: Maintain spotless employee records in Paylocity, handling new hire setups, status changes, and regular system audits.
- Keep Timekeeping on Track: Partner with local auction leaders to audit timecards, track attendance, manage PTO accruals, and fix discrepancies before deadline.
- Stay Compliant: Ensure strict adherence to federal, state, and local wage/hour laws, final pay rules, and tax regulations.
- Support Our People: Serve as the go-to escalation point for employee pay questions and self-service portal troubleshooting—always keeping records strictly confidential.
- Improve Processes: Spot bottlenecks, streamline workflows, and build custom reports in Paylocity and Excel for HR and Finance.
What You Bring as a Senior Payroll Specialist
- Experience: 4+ years of hands-on, high-volume, multi-state payroll processing experience.
- Tech Savvy: Strong HRIS/payroll system skills (Paylocity experience is a huge plus!).
- Microsoft Excel: Microsoft Excel skills, including VLOOKUP/XLOOKUP, Pivot Tables, and large data reconciliations, are a plus but not required.
- Compliance Know-How: Solid grasp of multi-state payroll tax laws, FLSA rules, and garnishment handling.
- Soft Skills: Razor-sharp attention to detail, ability to juggle competing priorities under tight deadlines, and great communication skills to explain policies clearly.
- Education: Associate's degree in Accounting, Business, or Human Resources preferred; equivalent experience may be substituted for education.
America’s Auto Auction is an equal opportunity employer. Responsibilities and requirements may evolve to meet business needs.
Salary Description $68,000.00 - $72,000.00More live payroll_specialist roles
- Dc Payroll Associate / Pracownik Ds. Kadr I Płac (M/K/X) at H&M Group — Gądki, Województwo wielkopolskie, PL
- Payroll Specialist at MACT Health Board — Angels Camp, CA
- Payroll Specialist at Keystone Rural Health Center — Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Albers Aerospace — McKinney, Texas, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Trilogy Health Services — Louisville, Kentucky, United States
- Payroll Assistant at Pacific National Exhibition — Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
- Multi State Payroll Specialist at Quipt Home Medical — Wilder, Kentucky, US
- Payroll & Benefits Specialist at Sandestin Investments — Miramar Beach, FL, US
- Payroll Clerk at The Kostelic Agency — Phoenix, AZ, United States
- UKG Payroll and Benefits Specialist at Cota Coaching and Consulting — Sioux Falls, South Dakota, United States
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Baylor Genetics — Houston, Texas, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Dentons — Calgary, AB, Canada
- Payroll Analyst at Storio group — Amsterdam, Netherlands, Netherlands
- French Payroll Specialist at CloudPay (Remote)
- Payroll Assistant Manager at SW Group — Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Usic — Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Senior Payroll Accountant at Ōura (Remote)
- Benefits and Payroll Specialist at Healthmap Solutions (Remote)
- Payroll Specialist at State Electric Jobs — Huntington, WV, US
- Payroll & Benefits Administrator at Freeman Mathis & Gary — Atlanta, Georgia, United States
- Executive & Payroll Assistant at New Opportunities — Waterbury, CT, United States
- Payroll Specialist/HR Technician at Pleasant Ridge Union Elementary School District — Grass Valley, California, United States
- Payroll And Benefits Analyst at Freeman Mathis & Gary — Atlanta, Georgia, United States
- Payroll Specialist at TRP Infrastructures — Haltom City, Texas, United States
- Payroll Associate at Viejas Casino & Resort — United States
- Payroll Specialist at North County Regional — Chatsworth, CA, US
- Payroll Specialist at The Dixon Group — Chestertown, Maryland, United States
- Payroll and Benefits Manager at Madison-Kipp Corporation — Madison, Wisconsin, United States
- Payroll Specialist at William S. Hart Union High School District — Santa Clarita, CA, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Hire Solutions — Brooklyn, New York, United States
- Human Resources / Payroll Clerk at Southern Berkshire Regional — Sheffield, Massachusetts, United States
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Hampton Lumber — Portland, Oregon, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Seyfarth Shaw — Chicago, Illinois, United States
- Workday Payroll Analyst Ii at Republic Services (Remote)
- Payroll Specialist at Sun Life — 2 Locations
- Associate Brazil Payroll Specialist at CloudPay France — San Jose, Costa Rica
- Payroll Specialist I at Insperity — Brea, CA
- Payroll Specialist Ii at Honeywell Aerospace — San Luis Potosi, SLP, Mexico
- Payroll Specialist Ii - North America at Emerson — Escazú, San José, Costa Rica
- Payroll Specialist (Temporary) at KION — Pallejà, Barcelona, Spain
- Senior Payroll Analyst at STV — Douglassville, Pennsylvania
- Payroll Analyst Ii at Jabil — Chihuahua
- Payroll and Benefits Specialist at Space Ops — Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Midwest Veterinary Supply — Lakeville, Minnesota, United States
- Payroll Associate/Coordinator at Macmillan — United States, United States, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Peel District School Board — Ontario, Ontario, Canada
- Payroll & Benefits Coordinator at eHealth Saskatchewan — Regina, SK, Canada
- Payroll Associate at Washington University in St Louis (Remote)
- Payroll Specialist at LiveCA (Remote)
- Senior Payroll Accountant at Oura (Remote)
- Payroll Specialist at Reunion Resort and Golf Club — Kissimmee, Florida, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Quartermaster — Arlington, Virginia, United States
- Payroll Specialist at The Pivot Group Network — Jackson, Michigan, US
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Matrix Communications — Plymouth, Minnesota, United States
- Human Resources & Payroll Specialist at The Kings Academy — Sunnyvale, California, United States
- Senior Payroll & Benefits Global Manager at Kids2 — Atlanta, Georgia, United States
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Canvas — Huntsville, Alabama, United States
- Payroll Specialist at Reynoldsburg City School District — Reynoldsburg, Ohio, US
- Senior Payroll Specialist at Airco Service Company — Troy, Illinois, United States
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Payroll Specialist: a median of $62,500 across 4,322 priced postings. This posting advertises $68,000 to $72,000, 12% above that median. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure