Payroll & HRIS Coordinator

Who we are: The Police Athletic League (PAL) of New York City is an independent youth development nonprofit organization and has been a vibrant and vital institution, serving as an effective, critical bridge between police and communities across all five boroughs of the City since 1914. PAL operates diverse programs for children as young as 2 years old to young adults. Programs include Head Start, after-school programs and summer day camps for elementary, middle and high school youth, and summer Playstreets. PAL also runs evening teen centers and college readiness programs, youth employment, and juvenile justice programs. Staying true to PAL’s roots, a cornerstone of our youth development strategy includes offering competitive and recreational sports for children of all ages.  At PAL, we’re devoted to empowering communities and building the best places to work, and that goes for our own teams too. 

Position Summary: 

Reporting to the Director of Human Resources, the Payroll & HRIS Coordinator supports the accurate and efficient administration of PAL’s payroll processes and HR Information System. This role ensures timely and compliant payroll processing, maintains data integrity across all HRIS modules, and assists with system updates, audits, and reporting. The Coordinator serves as a key liaison between HR, Finance, and program teams to ensure consistency between payroll and HR data, troubleshoots issues within the HRIS, and supports process improvements that enhance accuracy, compliance, and overall employee experience.  

What you’ll do:  

Payroll Administrative Support 

• Reviews and identifies errors or missing data on timesheets and communicates to staff and managers to ensure timesheet completeness for payroll. 

• Ensures employees are completing timesheets weekly – follow procedures for staff reminders and emails regarding time sheet completeness. 

• Processes payroll for hourly and salaried employees as needed. 

• Provides assistance in entering and paying all wage garnishments. 

• Ensures payroll deductions and withholdings are accurate. 

• Supports the Payroll Administrator to conduct audits ensuring accuracy and maintaining data integrity. 

• Files personnel data status forms, voluntary deductions and similar documents.  

• Updates and maintains a list of issues/items to track changes in payroll.  

• Prepares standard manual checks payroll and escalates issues to Payroll Administrator in a timely manner.  

• Supports training initiatives with the payroll team to coordinate suitable training solutions for employees 

HRIS Administration and Management  

• Serves as the primary administrator for PAL’s HRIS (Paycom), including system configuration, user access, and troubleshooting. 

• Maintains data integrity through regular audits and updates across all HR modules. 

• Manages employee data throughout the full lifecycle (onboarding, job/comp changes, leaves, separations, offboarding). 

• Ensures timely processing of Personnel Action Forms within the system to enable efficient process of changes to employee roles 

• Manages PAL organizational data in the HRIS  

• Supports the recruiting team to clean up inactive vacant positions or posted roles. 

• Coordinates with HR, Finance, and program teams to ensure seamless integration between payroll and HR systems. 

• Collaborates with the HRIS vendor to resolve technical issues, submit enhancement requests, and ensure optimal system functionality. 

• Ensures that all HRIS modules (including Time & Attendance, Benefits, and Applicant Tracking) are updated and aligned with current practices. 

• Assists in identifying and working on opportunities for process improvements and implementation of new forms and workflows within the systems such as Performance evaluation templates, job descriptions templates, and approval of workflows.  

Reporting and Compliance 

• Generates accurate and timely HR and payroll reports to support audits, compliance, and decision-making. 

• Develops and maintain standard and ad hoc reports for HR metrics, funder/grant reporting, and compliance tracking. 

• Prepares data for financial, insurance, pension, and government audits. 

• Supports data analysis for performance evaluations, training completion, and leave management. 

Training and Support 

• Provides technical assistance and training to employees and managers on HRIS functionality, time entry, and payroll processes. 

• Identifies opportunities to streamline HR workflows and leverage the HRIS to improve efficiency. 

• Promotes open communication and a culture of feedback and service excellence. 

Other HR Operations and Administrative Tasks 

• Learns the functions and protocols of the payroll team in order to assist timely and accurate processing of PAL’s payroll, identify areas to make improvements for efficiency and accuracy and make recommendations.   

• Reviews and reconcile monthly credit card statements to ensure accuracy, proper documentation, and compliance with organizational policies. 

• Prepares and process payment vouchers with accurate coding, documentation, and approvals to ensure timely and compliant payments. 

• Provides support for Payroll Administrator and the Director of HR in payroll reports or other reconciliation or audit reporting for the HR department.  

• Be the main point of contact for file storage and retrieval – for both physical and electronic files.  

• Supports other critical administrative HR functions as requested by the Payroll Administrator.  

• Supports other areas of HR as needed and directed by the Payroll Administrator or the Director of Human Resources 

Who you are/What you bring:  

• Bachelor’s degree or associate's degree in accounting, Human Resources, Human Business Administration, or related field;  

• 1+ years of experience in Payroll Administration or payroll processing 

• Payroll system software (e.g., Paycom preferred) and Microsoft Office Suite Data Management and or other reporting tools is preferred 

• Accurate data entry skills and attention to detail 

• Excellent Microsoft excel skills and quality control checking, data management 

• Excellent organizational skills and Detail-oriented 

• Strong analytical skills with the ability to interpret and present information effectively. 

• Excellent problem-solving abilities 

• Excellent interpersonal skills with the ability to manage sensitive and confidential situations with tact, professionalism, and diplomacy.  

Compensation: The range for this role is $32.96/hr 

Work Hours: 9am – 5pm, Monday - Friday 

Benefits: PAL offers a comprehensive benefits package for full-time employees which includes health insurance, PTO, an employee assistance program, training and more!  

Location: This is a hybrid role; office presence is required at our headquarters located at 34 1/2 East 12th Street, New York, NY 10003.   

Start date: As soon as possible  

At the Police Athletic League, we seek people who are talented, creative and passionate to help create a more inclusive city and better futures for our youth. We’re devoted to empowering communities and building the best places to work, and that goes for our own teams too. 

The Police Athletic League is an inclusive equal opportunity employer committed to recruiting and retaining a diverse workforce and providing a work environment that is free from discrimination and harassment based upon any legally protected characteristic including, but not limited to, an individual’s sex, race, color, ethnicity, national origin, age, religion, disability, sexual orientation, veteran status, gender identity, or pregnancy 

Employment with PAL is contingent upon successful completion of all the Agency’s lawful pre-employment checks, which may include a background check.