Collections Manager
Community First Credit Union • Neenah, WI • Full Time
Posted on Tue, Oct 20, 2026
As the Collections Manager (Member Solutions), you will help lead the credit union's collections function, with ultimate responsibility for protecting CFCU's assets while providing fair, respectful, and solutions-oriented service to members experiencing financial difficulty. You will provide leadership, direction, coaching, and oversight to the Member Solutions Specialists, and manage the resolution of seriously delinquent consumer and real estate accounts - from payment arrangements and workouts to legal action, repossession, foreclosure, and bankruptcy.
This role blends people leadership with deep collections expertise, working closely with the VP of Member Solutions, teams across the credit union, and third-party providers and vendors to maintain compliance with federal and state regulations and protect both members and the organization.
As the Collections Manager (Member Solutions) with CFCU, you will:
- Lead and develop the team. Lead, manage, coach, and develop the Collections/Member Solutions Specialist team to achieve departmental goals while fostering a collaborative, professional, and member-focused culture.
- Monitor performance and trends. Monitor collection trends, identify emerging risks and opportunities, and prepare and communicate management reports on collection trends, risks, and results to the VP of Member Solutions.
- Manage delinquent and troubled accounts. Oversee collection activity involving seriously delinquent consumer loans, mortgages, credit cards, and other at-risk accounts, determining appropriate next steps including payment arrangements, workouts, legal action, or charge-off.
- Serve as an escalation point. Act as a resource for complex, sensitive, or high-risk collection situations, including mortgages, and escalate significant credit, legal, or compliance risks to leadership.
- Oversee repossession and OREO activity. Manage all phases of repossession and OREO properties, from authorization and recovery through disposition, remarketing, and final closing.
- Ensure regulatory compliance. Maintain advanced knowledge of federal and Wisconsin collections laws and regulations, and ensure departmental practices comply with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, Fair Credit Reporting Act, and other applicable requirements.
- Partner across the organization. Work with debt management programs, debt settlement companies, third-party providers, and legal resources to evaluate and recommend proposed arrangements.
We are looking for a combination of:
- High school diploma or equivalent required; bachelor's degree in business, finance, accounting, paralegal studies, or a related field preferred. An equivalent combination of education and experience will always be considered.
- Five+ years of progressive experience in collections, lending, credit administration, financial services, bankruptcy, repossession, foreclosure, legal collections, or a related field preferred.
- Prior supervisory or management experience, including demonstrated responsibility for leading, coaching, and developing employees.
- Significant experience with complex collections involving bankruptcy, repossession, foreclosure, litigation, credit reporting, and/or troubled real estate accounts.
- Credit union, community banking, or other financial institution experience strongly preferred.
- Strong financial analysis and problem-solving skills with the ability to evaluate multiple alternatives and determine the strategy that best protects CFCU's assets.
- Excellent negotiation, conflict resolution, listening, verbal, and written communication skills.
- Ability to communicate professionally with members, attorneys, trustees, courts, vendors, real estate professionals, and other third parties.
- Strong organizational skills and exceptional attention to detail.
AuditFriendly salary estimate
The employer did not post a salary for this role. Based on AuditFriendly's salary intelligence model (comparable live postings, role, seniority, and location), we estimate base pay of $81,000–$99,000 per year (median ~$90,000). This is an AuditFriendly estimate, not an employer-provided figure.
More live collections_manager roles
- Students Accounts Collections Manager at Texas A&M — Commerce, Texas, United States
- Senior Collections Manager at Medline — Northfield, MN, United States
- Senior Lending And Collections Manager at Nuvei (Remote)
- Students Accounts Collections Manager at East Texas A&M University — Commerce, Texas, United States
- Collections Manager at Vibe Credit Union — Waterford, Michigan, United States
- Collections Manager at Highmark Credit Union — Rapid City, South Dakota, US
- Credit & Collections Manager at Fortive (Remote)
- Insurance Collections Manager at BLACKSTONE MEDICAL SERVICES — Tampa, Florida, United States
- Collections Manager at Rhino Tool House — New Berlin, WI, United States
- Collections Manager at Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings — San Antonio, Texas, United States
- Medical Billing And Collections Manager at The Behavioral Wellness Center at Girard — Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
- Billing & Collections Manager at Trilogy Health Services — Hudsonville, Michigan, United States
- Credit and Collections Manager at West Music Company — Coralville, Iowa, United States
- Front Line Collections Manager at GreenSky Administrative Services — Atlanta, Georgia, United States
- Collections Manager at Dataprise (Remote)
- Collections Manager at Family & Children's Services Career Center — Tulsa, Oklahoma, United States
- Collections Manager at American Motorcycle Association — Pickerington, Ohio, United States
- Collections Manager at CADOGAN TATE NEW YORK — Dallas, Texas, United States
- Cellular Therapy Collections Manager at Blood Assurance — Nashville, Tennessee, United States
- Assistant Collections Manager at Mount Vernon — Mount Vernon, Virginia, United States
- Billing and Collections Manager at Tucker Ellis — Columbus, Ohio, United States
- End User Collections Manager at Rite-Hite — Wisconsin, United States
- Credit and Collections Manager at Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren SC — Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States
- Collections Manager at FreeStar Financial Credit Union — Chesterfield Township, Michigan, United States
- Credit & Collections Manager at Omnimax Careers — Peachtree Corners, Georgia, United States
- Billing & Collections Manager at PACS Group — United States
- Billing and Collections Manager at PACS Group — United States
- Regional Collections Manager at Superior Auto — Washington, IN, US
- Collections Manager at CACI — Macdill AFB, FL, US
- Collections Manager at SambaSafety — Albuquerque, New Mexico, US
- Collections Manager at SAFE Credit Union — Folsom, California, United States
- Collections Manager at Biz2Credit — Miami, Florida, US
- Collections Manager at Commonwealth Care Of Roanoke — Roanoke, Virginia, United States
What the data says about this job
- Advertised pay for Collections Manager: a median of $76,500 across 199 priced postings. Explore the market
Measured from employers' own postings and public filings. How we measure